Should You Take Business Advice That Contradicts Your Instincts?

Photo by Austin Distel on Unsplash

“Go with your gut.” It’s an appealing phrase that encourages business owners, professionals, and talented individuals everywhere to stop overanalyzing a situation, and instead rely on their instincts to make an important decision.

But in the business world, you’ll have plenty of hard evidence, anecdotal evidence, and input from others to guide your decision-making. You’ll have partners, mentors, coworkers, and even friends and family members giving you advice for the development of your business.

So what happens when your instincts contradict a piece of advice given to you by someone you respect — or even multiple people you respect? Should you take their advice even if it contradicts your gut feeling?

The Case for Instincts

There’s no scientific rubric that allows you to test the true “power” of your instincts, and many entrepreneurs choose to trust their instincts because of some supernatural quality, akin to a superstition that can’t be proven or disproven. Ignoring that, let’s look at some of the practical, logical reasons why you might trust your instincts over outside advice:

· Snap judgments. Our brains evolved for escaping high-stakes scenarios that didn’t offer much room for contemplation; accordingly, we’re hard-wired to make snap judgments about our surroundings, and the evidence suggests we’re pretty darn good at it. Your “instincts,” in some cases, are merely the product of your experience, your beliefs, and a high-level assessment of a given scenario — think of it like your subconscious mind doing all the problem-solving work for you, making a reasonable estimation rather than precisely calculating the “right” answer. Accordingly, you’ll find that many of your snap judgments and decisions turn out to be correct — but only if you have the experience necessary to back them up. For example, a novice chess player wouldn’t be able to “feel” like a move is correct the same way a grandmaster would.

· Mavericks. Some of the most successful businesses are the ones whose brands are unlike anything else on the market. They’re the ones who dared to do what everyone else was afraid to, and the ones who kept going despite people telling them not to. Following the advice of the majority will lead you down the path of the majority — to moderate, but never breakout success. The argument here is that if you want a chance at standing out from the crowd, you have to go against the grain at least some of the time.

· Satisfaction. Don’t neglect the importance of your decision’s aftermath. Imagine a scenario in which, against your instinct, you followed the advice of a mentor. Ultimately, this leads you down a terrible path that results in losing a major client — chances are, you’d have a hard time forgiving yourself for not going with your gut to begin with. But if you make your own decision and fail, you’ll at least accept responsibility for your own destiny.

Main Problems to Consider

Don’t let these arguments fool you into believing that your instincts are always right, however. Consider the following problems:

· Experience. First, if you’re a new entrepreneur, remember that there are many more people who are far more experienced than you are. Your capacity for snap judgments is limited, and people wiser than you have likely been through this situation before. Remain humble in your early stages, and trust the more experienced people around you. You don’t have to agree with them on everything, but at least listen to what they have to say.

· Survivorship bias. The “maverick” argument may be convincing, but don’t forget our view of successful entrepreneurs is affected by survivorship bias. Essentially, we only hear stories about the entrepreneurs who contradicted advice and ended up becoming millionaires — not the people who contradicted advice and became failures. Keep this in mind before you try emulating your favorite celebrity business owner.

· Evidence and intuition. Remember that evidence exists as an objective reality, and intuition exists as a subjective feeling. Using your feelings to contradict evidence is often unwise; for example, “believing” that the traffic light is green doesn’t change the fact that it’s red. However, in the absence of evidence, intuition can help you fill in the gaps.

· Limitations of snap judgments. Snap judgments may often end up correct, but that doesn’t mean they have a perfect track record. If you’ve ever jumped in fright after seeing a mannequin in a dimly lit room, you know this all too well.

When it comes to making a tough decision, prioritize objective information as much as you can — no amount of instinct should overrule significant and clear evidence that contradicts your gut feeling. But in cases where the “right” answer isn’t clear, where evidence is fuzzy, and where you fundamentally disagree with your partners, let your instinct guide you in the right direction. Decisiveness is more important than always making the perfect decision, so pick a direction and stick with it.

For more content like this, be sure to check out my podcast, The Entrepreneur Cast!

CEO of EmailAnalytics (, a productivity tool that visualizes team email activity, and measures email response time. Check out the free trial!